法律是否重要——来自华南的一个民间收债案例     被引量：15

Is Law Important:Based on an informal debt-collection practice in South-east China

中文题名：法律是否重要——来自华南的一个民间收债案例

作者：徐昕

第一作者：徐昕

机构：[1]海南大学法学院副教授,博士

年份：2004

期号：1

起止页码：53-63

中文期刊名：社会学研究

中文关键词：法律实证主义;法律地位;债权保障;债务纠纷;民间收债;经济效益;东门市;

摘要：Is law important? It depends on one's conception of law and on what one considers important. Based on a field study of an informal debt-collection practice, the article describes a dispute settlement without court. The informal mechanism is consonant with economic theory, and is so effective,in short, the debtors are inclined to choose cooperation when the creditors take self-help remedies, and it results in order without law. As for the informal debt-collection I surveyed, state and society come to a tacit conspiracy, and the state tolerates the existence of self-help to a “proper extent”, which is a kind of the art of government that public power attains social control through private individuals' actions have a greater impact on behavior than the law does.

分类号：D923.3[债权]

收录：BDHX:【BDHX2000】；CSSCI:【CSSCI2004_2005】；国家哲学社会科学学术期刊数据库;中国人文社科核心期刊;社科基金资助期刊;核心刊;